Welcome, Guest
Username: Password: Remember me


CBS or NBC 4 years 5 days ago #108924

  • Mherbert10
  • Mherbert10's Avatar
  • Whats A Golf Forum?
  • Posts: 12
  • Thank you received: 1
I've heard a lot of debate surrounding this issue recently and I wanted to start a forum on it: which is better CBS or NBC? Obviously CBS has a more famous crew with the likes of Jim Nantz and Nick Faldo, but I've been liking NBC more recently. CBS has had an obscene amount of commercials, and NBC has used protracer much more often as well as the new wind graphic they have, both of which I love. I love Jim Nantz, and nothing beats the Masters coverage, but I'm really not a Nick Faldo fan. He seems to make a TON of off topic comments and I have counted (no joke) 5 comments over the past year where he referred to a player as having "a healthy pair of forearms" (What?). Also with the addition of David Feherty as well as broadcasts of the Open Championship and Olympics NBC is trending upwards. I have also found I really like Dan Hicks. Although I will say I cannot stand Johnny Miller. He seldom contributes anything positive or helpful to the broadcast and criticizes the best players in the world arrogantly and incessantly. What do you guys think? Obviously we can all agree, Fox is the worst!

CBS or NBC 4 years 4 days ago #108926

  • biggjonvic
  • biggjonvic's Avatar
  • GolfBalled Junkie
  • Posts: 707
  • Thank you received: 161
Great thought process, and for me anytime David Feherty is on a broadcast, that's the one I am watching. I wish he would have more of a role other than interviews, or a hole reporter, because you don't hear him as much. I agree about Johnny Miller. I think Feherty should replace him in the booth and put Miller on the course. If it was not for Jim Nantz, CBS would totally blow in my opinion.
Driver - Tour Edge HL3
Woods - Callaway Fit XTreme 3 and 5 wood
Hybrid - Callaway RAZR X 4H / 5H Tour Edge HL3
Irons - Callaway XHOT 2 6-PW
Wedges - Cleveland RTX-1 52, 56, 60
Putter - SeeMore
Balls - OnCore Caliber / Srixon Q Star Tour

CBS or NBC 4 years 4 days ago #108931

  • tmvds
  • tmvds's Avatar
  • GolfBalled Junkie
  • Posts: 2025
  • Thank you received: 375
NBC. I love Maltby and prob the only person here who also loves Johnny Miller, he is abrasive but normally correct. Peter Jacobsen is the worst though, I can tell you what he's going to say and proved it to my wife during Bay Hill. They showed Sam Saunders and I said "he'll mention he's Arnold Palmer's grandson" They showed Eric Compton and I said "he'll mention his heart transplants". and about 10 other examples and my wife says "you either watch too much golf or this guy just says the same things over and over again". Indeed. Don't bring up Payne Stewart or you will hear about Jake Trout and the Flounders. Did I mention that Peter Jacobsen is the worst?

Jim Nantz needs to narrate Harlequin romance novels and move away from golf, nauseating pontifications on trivial crap.

Did I mention that I love Maltby? LOL
Driver: Callaway Rogue, UST V5 shaft
Fairway: Titleist 915f 15 degree
Hybrid: Titleist 915
Irons: Ping i200
Wedges: Vokey 56* PXG 60*
Putter: EVNRoll ER9
Ball: Snell My Tour Ball
  • Mherbert10
  • Mherbert10's Avatar
  • Whats A Golf Forum?
  • Posts: 12
  • Thank you received: 1
Best Peter Jacobson quote was during the 2016 Hyundai Tournament of Champions when one of their scenic shots before break was of a whale and commentators say something along the lines of "Jordan Spieth leads them all in Maui" to sum up the current situation while out of nowhere Jacobson goes "did you know that the humpback whale is a distant cousin of the hippopotamus?" I don't think I've laughed so hard in my life. But I do like Jacobson, he's repetitive but sometimes pretty funny especially when it comes to nature comments.

CBS or NBC 4 years 2 days ago #109002

  • MulliganAgain
  • MulliganAgain's Avatar
  • Administrator
  • Posts: 3707
  • Thank you received: 955
When I think of Jim Nantz, or atleast hear his voice, I think of College Basketball. Not Golf. I actually prefer almost any commentator.
Driver: Cobra Fly-Z,
Woods: Ping G30 3 & 5 Wood
Hybrid: Nike Vapor Flex 4-Hybrid
Irons: WilsonStaff C200 or Mizuno JPX EZ
Wedges: Cleveland Golf RTX 2.0 56*, 60*
Putter: Cleveland Golf - Classic Black Platinum 5.5 with Winn Giant Pistol Grip
Bag: SunMountain PHANTOM

Instagram: sean_likes_golf

CBS or NBC 4 years 2 days ago #109006

  • Laddog54
  • Laddog54's Avatar
  • GolfBalled Junkie
  • Posts: 1527
  • Thank you received: 114
I'm a Johnny Miller fan ( I guess being old and grumpy, I like it when he just blitzes someone) and when you add Ferehty NBC is my favorite. I still think Nantz is the best.
10.5* Wilson D100 Matrix Ozik 4.1 reg
Bombtech Grenade 5w
18* Callaway X-Hot Pro Hybrid 5.5 Project X Velocity
4-6 Wilson D100 ES Hybrids Matrix Ozik Altus 5.6 Stiff
7-GW Wilson D100 ES irons Matrix Studio 6.1 stiff (all won on GB)
Callaway X Jaws 50*-12 pw
Wilson R90 54* sw
Mizuno Raw Blk Oxide...
Last Edit: 4 years 2 days ago by Laddog54.